Express Global

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Monday, 18 November 2013

McIntyre demonstrates new warmist study still shows IPCC climate models greatly exaggerate global warming

Posted on 11:23 by Unknown
In a post today, Steve McIntyre demonstrates that the new warmist study by Cowtan & Way [that allegedly gets rid of the 17 year 'pause' in global warming] still shows that the IPCC models greatly exaggerate global warming, and that this difference is much greater than the small difference in temperature datasets:






In the context of IPCC SOD FIgure 1.5 (or similar comparison of models and observations), CW13 is slightly warmer than HadCRUT4 but the difference is small relative to the discrepancy between models and observations; the CW13 variation is also outside the Figure 1.5 envelope.cowtanway2013 vs ipcc ar5sod figure 1_5
Figure 1. Cowtan and Way 2013 hybrid plotted onto IPCC AR5SOD Figure 1.5
Next, here is a simple plot showing the difference between the CW13 hybrid and HadCRUT 4. Up to the end of 2005, there was a zero trend between the two; the difference has arisen entirely since 2005. [added: this is very odd and remains unexplained]


cowtanway2013_difference between hadcru4 and cw2013The models have been falsified at confidence levels of 90% to 95% to 98%+ over the past 15-35 years, and thus this warmist paper does little to resurrect their cause:




In addition, McIntyre notes that 


"co-author Way was an active participant at the secret SKS forum, where he actively fomented conspiracy theory allegations. Uniquely among participants in the secret SKS forum, he conceded that Climate Audit was frequently correct in its observations (“The fact of the matter is that a lot of the points he brings up are valid”) and said of Climate Audit (“I wouldn’t want to go up against that group, between them there is a lot of statistical power to manipulate and make the data say what it needs to say.”)


More on the Skeptical Science [SkS] secret forum:


‘…we need a conspiracy to save humanity’

LOL! ‘Mad Haxor Skillz’ Godwinize ‘Skeptical Science’

Secret Skeptical Science






More on the paper by Cotwan & Way:

Climate magic: New Study now claims the Global warming pause never was! Study claims ‘to have discovered that the pause is illusory and due to incorrect estimates of temperatures at the poles’

Judith Curry is having fun with the paper, noting that the methods they use to estimate the missing data are not exactly suited in the particular circumstances of polar temperatures: the statistical infilling technique of kriging 'makes no physical sense' when applied across land/ocean/sea ice boundaries




Climatologist Dr. Judith Curry on the Cowtan & Way ‘pausebuster’: ‘Is there anything useful [in it]?’
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to Facebook
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Executive Summary of the NIPCC Climate Change Reconsidered II Report
    Executive Summary from the NIPCC Climate Change Reconsidered II Report, released 9/16/13: Executive Summary  This report is produced by the ...
  • New paper finds South Pacific rainfall was up to 2.4 times more variable before the 20th century
    A new paper published in Geology reconstructs climate of the South Pacific over the past 446 years and "shows rainfall varied much mor...
  • New Material Posted on the NIPCC Web site
    New Material Posted on the NIPCC Web site Species Range Shifts in a Warming World (19 Nov 2013) It is considerably more complex - and conser...
  • WSJ: Fracking has done more for the poor than all of Obama's ministrations combined
    More on Fracking and the Poor The U.S. oil and gas boom added $1,200 to disposable income in 2012. Last week we reported on a study showing ...
  • Where, Oh Where, Has that Global Warming Gone?
    Terrifying Flat Global Temperature Crisis Threatens To Disrupt U.N. Climate Conference Agenda By Larry Bell, Forbes, 9/10/13 Bummer! Now, ju...
  • New paper finds chaotic response to natural climate drivers ENSO and solar activity
    A paper under open review for Climate of the Past reconstructs climate and levels of 9 lakes in East Africa and finds the climate of East A...
  • New paper finds IPCC climate models don't realistically simulate convection
    More problems for the models: A paper published today in Geophysical Research Letters finds climate models do not realistically simulate co...
  • Special Report: The Age of Plenty debunks alarmist claims of food shortages
    Paging Paul Ehrlich :  IEEE Spectrum , the journal of the world's largest professional association for the advancement of technology, ha...
  • Yale Climate Forum stumped by simple question on sea levels
    In response to the article The Inevitability of Sea-Level Rise posted at the Yale Forum on Climate Change & the Media, I asked the foll...
  • New paper finds another non-hockey-stick in Sweden
    A paper in open review for Climate of the Past reconstructs temperatures in northern Sweden for the past 800 years and finds another non-ho...

Blog Archive

  • ►  2014 (20)
    • ►  January (20)
  • ▼  2013 (480)
    • ►  December (77)
    • ▼  November (64)
      • New paper finds the South China Sea is a net sourc...
      • New paper demonstrates inability to model clouds
      • New paper finds lakes under Greenland ice sheet; '...
      • Graph of the Day: Major US Hurricane Drought Conti...
      • New Report Concludes That Extreme Weather Events A...
      • Meteorologist's poll finds no consensus on climate...
      • NOAA: 2013 had fewest hurricanes since 1982 and no...
      • The Sun explains 95% of climate change over the pa...
      • New paper rules out volcanoes as the cause of the ...
      • New paper finds Greenland ice sheet is 'insensitiv...
      • Governments frightened off at UN climate talks by ...
      • New Material Posted on the NIPCC Web site
      • Climate Change Alarm Is A U.N. Extortion Racket
      • Climate science lawyers up
      • New paper finds ocean crustaceans not affected by ...
      • A Change of Carbon Climate in Japan
      • UN climate conference is all about wealth redistri...
      • UN COP19 Progress Report: China demands compensati...
      • Hansen's NASA GISS data confirm the Arctic was war...
      • New paper explains how natural ocean oscillations ...
      • New paper finds Arctic temperatures peaked before ...
      • New paper finds evidence of Svensmark's cosmic ray...
      • New paper confirms the Sun was particularly active...
      • New paper finds warming has also 'paused' in the A...
      • McIntyre demonstrates new warmist study still show...
      • NCAR scientist admits IPCC may be wrong on clouds,...
      • Big Ethanol Finally Loses
      • New paper suggests volcanoes are causing Antarctic...
      • IPCC's Confidence Grows as Models Get Worse
      • UN climate conference COP19 tells blatant lies to ...
      • Alarmist climate scientists have abused the public...
      • Was Haiyan the Strongest Storm Ever? No
      • New paper finds corals not affected by life-long e...
      • New research group to determine why Earth is still...
      • New paper finds simple laptop computer program rep...
      • New paper finds amplification mechanism by which t...
      • New paper finds a significant decreased temperatur...
      • Are Typhoon Disasters Getting More Common? No
      • Lomborg: Spain wastes hundreds of billions of doll...
      • New paper finds CFCs combined with other factors h...
      • Settled science: German scientists discover bacter...
      • New paper finds Pacific cyclone activity is at the...
      • New paper finds another erroneous assumption of th...
      • Obama's Ethanol Policies Have Scarred The Earth
      • New paper finds sea level rise has decelerated 44%...
      • New paper shows the 'simple basic physics' of gree...
      • New paper finds ice core CO2 levels lag temperatur...
      • New paper finds government green energy stimulus p...
      • Climate Con Artists Exploit Typhoon Haiyan
      • Global Warming Alarmists Are Overrun By The Facts
      • Note to IPCC: Correlation Does Not Equal Causation...
      • CERN scientist says another Maunder Minimum in sol...
      • Shock: CO2 could melt Antarctic ice cap & raise se...
      • Inconvenient truth: Fracking has cut CO2 emissions...
      • Observations Now Inconsistent with Climate Model P...
      • More free money! Computer model says global carbon...
      • AP: The secret, dirty cost of Obama's green power ...
      • New paper finds the Sun controls European & North ...
      • Does Environmentalism Cause Amnesia? Alarmism of f...
      • Analysis shows accumulated solar energy explains 2...
      • Obama issues executive order to insert his global ...
      • What is happening to the oceans?
      • The Obamacare meltdown continues: New report says ...
      • New paper finds US extreme heat waves have decreas...
    • ►  October (65)
    • ►  September (130)
    • ►  August (108)
    • ►  July (36)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile